
Can the Sources Carry the Claim? Smith, Powhatan and Pocahontas
Critique whether the sources behind a historical interpretation can support its claims
C3 Framework for Social Studies
History, geography, civics and economics.

Critique whether the sources behind a historical interpretation can support its claims

Analyze what changed and what stayed the same across a historical era

Analyze how historical contexts shaped people's perspectives and still shape them today

Explain how the perspectives of people in their present shape interpretations of the past

Tell long-term causes from triggering events to argue why the 1857 rebellion happened

Analyze a series of historical events and decide whether earlier events caused later ones

Find the central idea of a history source and summarize how its events or ideas develop

Cite specific evidence from primary and secondary sources, weighing their date and origin

Analyze how a history text's structure emphasizes key points and builds an explanation

Work out what political, social and economic words mean as used in history texts

Use questions to assess how the significance of people's actions changes with context

Critique the central argument of a history book, film, painting or poem for accuracy

Compare and contrast how several primary and secondary sources treat the same topic

Judge a source's usefulness for an inquiry by maker, date, place, audience and purpose

Integrate charts, tables and data with a history text to test and explain its claims

Detect limits in different kinds of historical evidence and in differing interpretations

Read and understand complex grades 9-10 history texts independently and proficiently

Compare authors' points of view on one topic and the details each includes and emphasizes

Analyze how a secondary interpretation selects, reads and goes beyond its primary sources

Analyze how multiple causes combined to start World War I and trace its complex effects

Use questions raised by several sources to pursue an inquiry and find additional sources

Analyze how the sources that survive limit our interpretations of people's perspectives

Assess how well the reasoning and evidence in a history text support the author's claims

Analyze the interacting factors that shaped people's perspectives in a past era

Integrate several primary sources and interpretations into one reasoned argument

Analyze how the perspectives of those writing history shaped the histories they produced