Can the Sources Carry the Claim? Smith, Powhatan and Pocahontas

A full lesson on critiquing the sources behind a historical interpretation: provenance, timing, motive, corroboration, silence and missing voices. Students test three accounts of John Smith's 1608 meeting with Powhatan against Smith's own 1608 and 1624 words.

First page of the worksheet “Can the Sources Carry the Claim? Smith, Powhatan and Pocahontas”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 10 worksheet.

Skill
Critique whether the sources behind a historical interpretation can support its claims
Time
About 210 minutes
Includes
52 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • C3 D2.His.13.9-12

    Judge whether the historical sources a secondary interpretation relies on are appropriate for the claims it makes.