Critique an Argument: Strong Parts and Weak Spots

A full lesson on judging an argument fairly: testing its evidence, checking its reasoning for traps like overgeneralizing and loaded words, and suggesting improvements. Includes two letters to the editor and Benjamin Franklin's 1784 bald eagle complaint.

First page of the worksheet “Critique an Argument: Strong Parts and Weak Spots”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 4 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 4
Skill
Critique an argument by testing its evidence, reasoning and fairness
Time
About 220 minutes
Includes
40 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • C3 D4.4.3-5

    Judge how strong an argument is by checking its claim, evidence and reasoning, and say how it could be better.