Is It a Good Explanation? How to Critique One

A full lesson on critiquing an explanation: find the question, check the facts, look for evidence, test each because-link, ask what is missing, then give a verdict and a fix. Uses the Great Fire of London and the diary of Samuel Pepys.

First page of the worksheet “Is It a Good Explanation? How to Critique One”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 4 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 4
Skill
Critique an explanation by checking its question, facts, evidence and because-links
Time
About 150 minutes
Includes
40 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • C3 D4.5.3-5

    Judge how well an explanation answers its question, uses accurate facts and evidence, and links causes to effects.