Does It Hold Up? Delineating and Evaluating an Argument

A full lesson on mapping an argument's claims, reasons and evidence, judging whether the reasoning is sound and the evidence relevant and sufficient, and spotting irrelevant evidence. Four arguments, including one on the dollar coin, with 36 questions.

First page of the worksheet “Does It Hold Up? Delineating and Evaluating an Argument”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 8 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 8
Skill
Map an argument and judge its reasoning and the relevance and sufficiency of its evidence
Time
About 230 minutes
Includes
39 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • CCSS RI.8.8

    Lay out an argument's claims and judge whether its reasoning is sound and its evidence relevant and sufficient, noticing evidence that does not belong.