When Sources Disagree: Conflicts of Fact and Interpretation

A full lesson on analyzing two texts that conflict on the same topic and pinpointing whether they disagree on facts or on interpretation. Four pairs: Napoleon's height, Mallory on Everest, Norse Greenland and the 1835 Moon Hoax. 36 questions.

First page of the worksheet “When Sources Disagree: Conflicts of Fact and Interpretation”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 8 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 8
Skill
Analyze two texts that conflict and identify disagreements of fact or of interpretation
Time
About 240 minutes
Includes
39 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • CCSS RI.8.9

    Analyze two or more texts that give conflicting information on one topic and pinpoint where they disagree about facts or about how to interpret them.