Write an Evaluation of an Argument: Reasoning and Evidence

An eighth grade writing lesson: trace an argument's claims, judge whether its reasoning is sound and its evidence relevant and sufficient, spot irrelevant evidence, and write an evaluation. 4 texts (one by John Muir), 25 items, 4 writing tasks.

First page of the worksheet “Write an Evaluation of an Argument: Reasoning and Evidence”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 8 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 8
Topic
Writing
Skill
Write an evaluation of an argument's claims, reasoning and evidence, citing the text
Time
About 270 minutes
Includes
28 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • CCSS W.8.9.B

    Use evidence from literary nonfiction to write an evaluation of an argument, tracing its claims, judging whether its reasoning is sound and its evidence relevant and sufficient, and pointing out irrelevant evidence.