History Sources: Weighing Competing Explanations

A full lesson on weighing rival explanations of historical events, choosing the best-supported one and naming what stays uncertain. Readings on Roanoke, the USS Maine, the Library of Alexandria and the Princes in the Tower; 36 questions and an essay.

First page of the worksheet “History Sources: Weighing Competing Explanations”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 12 worksheet.

Skill
Weigh rival explanations of an event, choose the best supported, state what is uncertain
Time
About 270 minutes
Includes
39 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • CCSS RH.11-12.3

    Evaluate different explanations for historical actions or events, decide which one best fits the evidence in the text, and acknowledge where the text leaves matters uncertain.