Weighing an Argument: Reasoning, Evidence and Fallacies

A full lesson on mapping an argument's claims, testing whether its reasoning is valid and its evidence relevant and sufficient, and catching false statements and fallacies. Two invented arguments, Theodore Roosevelt and Andrew Carnegie, with 38 questions.

First page of the worksheet “Weighing an Argument: Reasoning, Evidence and Fallacies”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 9 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 9
Skill
Evaluate an argument's reasoning and evidence and identify false statements and fallacies
Time
About 250 minutes
Includes
41 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • CCSS RI.9-10.8

    Lay out and judge an argument and its claims, deciding whether the reasoning is valid and the evidence relevant and sufficient, and spotting false statements and faulty reasoning.