Evaluate an Argument in Writing: Reasoning, Evidence, Fallacies

A grades 9 to 10 writing lesson: delineate an argument, judge whether its reasoning is valid and its evidence relevant and sufficient, catch false claims and fallacies, and write a fair evaluation. 3 arguments (one by Mill), 31 items, 4 writing tasks.

First page of the worksheet “Evaluate an Argument in Writing: Reasoning, Evidence, Fallacies”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 9 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 9
Topic
Writing
Skill
Evaluate an argument in writing: reasoning, evidence, false claims and fallacies
Time
About 300 minutes
Includes
34 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • CCSS W.9-10.9.B

    Use evidence from literary nonfiction to write an evaluation of an argument: lay out its claims, judge whether its reasoning is valid and its evidence relevant and sufficient, and identify false statements and fallacious reasoning.