Who Burned Chicago? Critiquing the Reasoning Behind Explanations

A full lesson on critiquing explanations: test the because-links, rebuild the timeline and weigh every supporting detail. Students apply the method to the official 1871 report on the Great Chicago Fire, Catherine O'Leary's sworn testimony and the cow legend.

First page of the worksheet “Who Burned Chicago? Critiquing the Reasoning Behind Explanations”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 9 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 9
Skill
Critique an explanation's reasoning, sequence of events and supporting details
Time
About 260 minutes
Includes
58 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • C3 D4.5.9-12

    Judge how well an explanation reasons from cause to effect, puts events in the right order and backs its claims with accurate, relevant and sufficient details.