How Experts Judge a Source: The Donation of Constantine

A full high school lesson on judging a source's credibility by how experts have valued it and why. Built on the Donation of Constantine, trusted for six centuries until scholars proved it a forgery, with three primary sources and a real expert check.

First page of the worksheet “How Experts Judge a Source: The Donation of Constantine”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 9 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 9
Skill
Judge a source's credibility by examining how experts have valued it and why
Time
About 235 minutes
Includes
45 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • C3 D3.2.9-12

    Decide how credible a source is by finding out how experts in the field have judged it, and by weighing the reasons behind their judgments.