Can You Believe It? Critiquing Arguments for Credibility

A full lesson on judging whether an argument deserves belief: checking its source, its evidence and its reasoning, and reading laterally. Includes Poe's 1844 balloon hoax, the failed 1936 Literary Digest poll, and a real credibility check.

First page of the worksheet “Can You Believe It? Critiquing Arguments for Credibility”
Download PDF

For members. Join for $119.88 a year to download every Grade 6 worksheet.

Grade
Grade 6
Skill
Critique an argument's credibility by checking its source, evidence and reasoning
Time
About 240 minutes
Includes
41 questions, answer key, teaching notes

Standards

  • C3 D4.4.6-8

    Judge whether an argument is credible by examining who made it, the quality of its evidence and the soundness of its reasoning.